Vogue, Lanvin dress, Daria Werbowy, photo courtesy of www.lindsayalbanese.comEveryday Glamour takes Valentine’s Day very seriously. The Valentine’s post needed to go deeper, to get to the real nitty gritty, and the clock was ticking. So I called up my mom for advise, and it went like this:
Me: Hey, Mom! I'm doing a Valentine's Day post. I have an untested theory that all men love Strawberry Shortcake. Do you have any stories about Strawberry Shortcake and men?
Mom: No, it’s Banana Bread. Fundamentally, all men love it. They find it very romantic.
The premise is established: The way to a man’s heart is through his stomach. Everyone knows that. But what I wanted to know was which desert gives a woman the most results for her efforts? I was convinced that it had to be Strawberry Shortcake, hands down. I wanted to get to the bottom of this, so I hatched a sneaky plan. And I needed to enlist the help of my sister-in-law:
Me: Hi! Ok, so I have a Valentine’s Day post idea for the blog and if you feel like it , it would be amazing if you could participate! I say all men love Strawberry Shortcake, and mom says no, it’s Banana Bread. So anyway, I was going to do an experiment. Without telling Ken, one day I will make Banana Bread. Another day I make Strawberry Shortcake from scratch. I measure the reaction for amorous behavior. Could you do the same with David before Feb. 14th?
Sister-in-Law: I heard different. First of all…the universal smell for men is vanilla, FACT!, and I heard all men are turned on by the smell of Cinnamon Buns.
So we decided to sneak around and make all three deserts for our men, Banana Bread, Cinnamon Buns, and Strawberry Shortcake, present them on different days with nonchalance, and stealthily observe their behavior.
Photo Vogue UK, courtesy of www.reinedeboheme.tumbler.com
Easy, right? Wrong. A few days later I heard back from my sister-in-law:
Sister-in-Law: Ok, here is the deal. David and I are trying to watch our weight so I’m not baking. I just asked him what’s sexier: Banana Bread, Cinnamon Buns, or Strawberry Shortcake. Banana Bread reminds him of Mom and Strawberry Shortcake is too cute. So Cinnamon Buns it is.
Me: This is SUCH BULL!!! Strawberry Shortcake made from scratch is totally manly!! Men love it!! Ken literally fell asleep at the table with the Banana Bread. Total fail. But with the Cinnamon Buns, he rubbed my leg and kept repeating this is so good. Make the Strawberry Shortcake, please? And Cinnamon Buns are so easy—get the Pillsbury ones you stick in the oven. C’mon!! Please!! You can’t go on a diet now, I have a blog to write! Ha, ha!
Photo by Annie Leibovitz, model Karlie Kloss, Vogue, July 2009, courtesy of www.geanimalisandru.wordpress.com
I thought I had talked some sense into her but then I heard from my brother:
Brother: Were you aware when you gave her this assignment that she can’t bake? It’s really funny watching her.
Me: Damn! You are not supposed to know!
Brother: Yes, it’s inherently a problem with the experiment. In my opinion, guys get turned on when a woman bakes anything for them because it shows their ability to function as a mother.
Me: Tell me the story!
Brother: Which means they will make great moms.
Me: Yeah, but Bro, Ken literally fell asleep after eating Banana Bread. I looked over at him and he had fallen asleep at the table! But with the Cinnamon Buns he was amorous. Ok, tell me more.
Brother: When I was 20, and I was just hanging out with Amy as friends, I remember she brought over a whole tray of cookies that she baked. It was game over at that point.
Me: Amy #1 or Amy #2?
Brother: One obviously!
Me: Ha,ha. Ok but tell me the story about your wife trying to bake.
Brother: Why does everyone ask that!???
Me: Sorry!
Brother: I don’t even think about #2.
Me: Amy #1 was better, I know! Teasing. It’s funny. It’s like "The Cat in the Hat". Thing One and Thing Two.
Brother: Ha, ha, ha! Thing One and Thing Two…Well, when I woke up, she was quietly struggling with a mixing bowl.
Me: Details!
Brother: She was using these flimsy, malleable-type bowls, which are meant for liquids, not mixing.
Me: Right. Ha, ha! Then what?
Brother: There’s a reason why mixing bowls are made of stainless steel.
Me: Ha, ha.
Brother: Then when I saw her she started laughing because she knows how bad she is at baking. She put the heterogeneous mix into a bread pan and then turned to me and asked if I wanted her to put nuts in it. Kinda late for that.
Me: So this is Banana Bread!
Brother: After it was in the oven a few minutes, she climbed into bed and pulled the sheets up to her face and said, “I don’t even know how long I’m supposed to bake it. I don’t even know how long it’s been in there.”
Me: I’m gonna kill her!
Brother: Yeah she told me about the whole experiment.
Me: Damn. I’m making Strawberry Shortcake now. Totally secret. Ken has no idea.
Brother: You’re not controlling for the nurturing effect. You need to have someone of the same gender give it to them. Or we get it ourselves.
Me: Well, you have a point…but this is not an experiment per se, it’s more observational and then compile the results. Unfortunately, all my friends are either single or on a diet. Generous eye roll. I still think Strawberry Shortcake is gonna be the winner here.
Brother: Cinnamon Buns.
Me: We will see now won’t we?
Well, I guess you all want to know what lit my husband’s fire. It was the Cinnamon Buns. I was pretty surprised. I used those easy Pillsbury ones that you stick in the oven. Buns from scratch are ten times better, but he doesn’t know that. The Strawberry Shortcake got fair results in the amorous department, but they were more work. Based on my results, I recommend that my readers bake up some Cinnamon Buns and serve with coffee in bed on Valentine’s Day morning. That’s the real nitty gritty.
But wait, there’s more to the story! Later my brother went to a wine and cheese party and got to talking about my little experiment. Three men, two medical students and an artist, all said they preferred Strawberry Shortcake. In fact, they seemed almost offended that there were alternatives other than the shortcake.
So click here for the recipe! Happy Valentine’s Day!